We had many erotic conversations about it, having another man joining in always seemed to get Michelle aroused and she proved it by getting extremely wet every time we talked about it. She usually followed shortly thereafter with an arousing orgasm from me eating her soaking wet cunt or even just masturbating her with my hand. I somehow believed she’d never go through with it, though. She’s a shy person (at first) and certainly wouldn’t approach anyone other than myself about the fantasy.
Recently my erotic story of having another guy came up more and more often and I started to think, “Maybe, just maybe she might go along with it.” Maybe if I surprised her one night by making sure it was completely dark and she couldn’t see that I have another guy in the room she wouldn’t have a chance to think and she would just have to react. After many weeks of exchanging e-mails with Peter, Michelle’s cyber lover, I thought he could “join us”. I arrange to meet with Peter at a local bar. He and I had exchanged erotic e-mails of what we would get up to with Michelle if we ever had the chance and had many bizarre talks about what fun it would be to sneak off with into the bathroom with my lovely wife! Anyway, I told him that I knew Michelle had the fantasy about having two guys at once, advising Peter to keep my wife’s identity a secret as she was unaware of what I was planning. He was definitely interested but wanted to know up to what stage of involvement I was prepared to allow it to go. I told him that Michelle wanted to keep her identity concealed, as she was too embarrassed. I assured him that the my wife was very horny and she would not disappoint him if he would agree to it. After a few good drinks and some coaxing I finally got him to agree to join.